It is a communication problem!

Really? Always?

The campaign was good. The emails went out. The intranet was updated. Managers received their talking points. The leadership team had its briefing. The launch of the new employee share plan was on time.  And yet, after three months, fewer than 12% of eligible employees had signed up. 

So what went wrong?  In many organizations, the answer arrives almost automatically: we have a communication problem. We take a closer look into what contributes to a satisfying – or poor outcome.

Communication is the key to success.

Yes – and no. There is a bit more to it: it may also be possible that employees are already worrying about their monthly bills and are reluctant to lock up more money in shares. Perhaps they do not trust the company’s future performance, or the platform is difficult to use on a phone between meetings. Also, managers may not feel confident enough to recommend participation. All of these possibilities might show up as low engagement. None is necessarily solved by sending another email. 

Communication gets the blame because it touches almost everything that happens between an organization and its people. When people do not understand, participate, change behavior, or respond as expected, communication is an easy place to look. 

But easy does not always mean accurate.

One of our projects is a clear proof of how all aspects must work together for success: 
After Vitesco became part of the Schaeffler Group in 2024, the company pension plan was harmonized across the group. In our Schaeffler case study you find more details on the campaign which resulted in an extraordinary acceptance rate of 70%. 

Communication has become both scapegoat and cure-all

We have created a strange paradox around communication. Almost anyone can be asked to “put something together,” yet when an initiative fails, communication is often held responsible for the outcome. 

A Total Rewards leader makes a decision. A project team develops the content. Someone eventually asks Comms to turn it into an announcement. Later, when people do not respond as expected, the question becomes whether Comms communicated it well enough. 

That puts communication professionals in an awkward position. 

A communication professional may be asked to make a complicated Total Rewards proposition understandable. That is a legitimate communication challenge. But if the proposition itself is poorly designed, the rules are unnecessarily complicated, or employees cannot see why it is relevant to them, the answer is not simply a better campaign.

A good campaign can make a strong proposition clearer. It cannot make a weak proposition stronger. 

The same applies to organizational change. Communication can explain what is changing, why it is changing, what it means for people, and what they need to do. It can build understanding and help people navigate complexity. 

It cannot create a strategy. It cannot create ownership where responsibility is unclear. And it cannot make people believe something they have good reason to question. 

Knowing the difference is part of the professional skill. 

New Bonus Program. Three situations. Three different problems.

1 – Communication
If employees do not understand the basic rules of the plan, you have a communication problem
2 – Design and leadership
If they understand the rules but believe the plan is unfair, you have a design and leadership problem
3 – Management and enablement
If they never hear about the plan because managers avoid the conversation, you have a management and enablement problem

Only the first can be solved by better communication alone.

Understanding is not agreement

Organizations often say they need to “communicate better” when what they really mean is: we need people to accept this. 

But those are not the same thing. People can understand a decision and disagree with it. They can understand that a benefit is being reduced and still feel that the burden is not being shared fairly. They can understand a change to the grading system and still worry about what it means for their career. They can understand the value of a benefit and still decide not to use it. 

That does not necessarily mean communication has failed. Treating disagreement as a communication failure can even be counterproductive. It can encourage organizations to send more information when what they actually need is to listen to what people are telling them. Sometimes what is needed is a conversation about the decision, not another explanation of it. 

The purpose of communication is not to persuade people to reach the answer the organization wants. It is to give people enough information, context, and understanding to make sense of a situation and, where appropriate, make informed decisions. 

At its most useful, communication helps people understand what is happening, why it matters, what it means for them, and what they need to do next. Sometimes the outcome will be the one the organization hoped for. Sometimes it will expose a problem that needs to be addressed elsewhere. Both are valuable. 

In practice, that requires more thinking than most organizations allow for. 

This is why communication needs to enter the conversation earlier than the moment when somebody needs an announcement.

If a Total Rewards team is redesigning its employee proposition, communication should not simply be asked at the end to explain the finished product. It can help test whether the proposition is understandable, what employees are likely to question, and where complexity might prevent people from engaging with it. 

The more useful questions come earlier. What business and people outcomes are we trying to achieve? What exactly needs to change in people’s behavior, decisions or participation? What do different employee groups need to understand to make a good decision? Where might people feel uncertainty, loss or unfairness? And what practical barriers, such as time, tools, processes or trust, could get in the way?

Before developing the communication, ask: 

⇒ What business and people outcomes are we trying to achieve?
⇒ What needs to change in people’s behavior, decisions or participation?
⇒ What does each employee group need to understand to make a good decision?
⇒ Where might people experience uncertainty, loss or unfairness?
⇒ What practical barriers, such as time, tools, processes or trust, could prevent action?

The answer may be communication. 
It may be leadership or governance. 
It may be the proposition or the project itself. 
Often, it will be a combination.

The work starts before the words.

That is why communication is not simply the ability to write, design, or deliver a message. It is the ability to understand what needs to be achieved, determine whether communication can contribute to that outcome, and develop the right response. The work starts with diagnosis, not delivery.

Who is actually responsible?

Leaders face a version of this too. Leadership communication is not the same as leaders doing all the communicating. A CEO does not need to personally deliver every message. A Total Rewards director does not need to write every employee announcement. 
But leaders cannot outsource responsibility for whether communication works.

They remain accountable for whether people have the information, context and support they need to do their work. For Total Rewards leaders, that means remaining responsible for whether employees can make informed decisions about their benefits, not simply whether an email has been sent. For HR, it means ensuring managers are equipped to have difficult conversations, not just that a toolkit exists on the intranet. 

The responsibility is not necessarily to be the sender. It is to create the conditions for communication to work. 

Before asking for better communication, ask a better question

For Boards, People leaders, and Total Rewards professionals, perhaps the more useful question is not: “How do we communicate this better?” It is:

What are we trying to achieve, what is getting in the way, and what role can communication realistically play?​
The answer determines what happens next. It stops communication becoming the default explanation for every disappointing outcome. It prevents organizations from throwing another email, campaign, or town hall at a problem that sits somewhere else. But it also stops communication being treated as an afterthought. Because when understanding, decisions, or behavior genuinely matter to the business, professional communication can make a significant difference. It is about understanding what needs to be achieved, what people need to know, and where communication can genuinely make a difference.  Good communication does not simply deliver the message. It helps make the work possible.

First things first.

Great communication starts long before the first word is written. At Unequity, we begin with a clear diagnosis of where you stand, what you want to achieve, and where to focus. Only then do we create. Our Explore–Engage–Shine process ensures that every message lands because it rests on a solid foundation. Clarity first. Impact follows. Start with Explore.

CONTACT US

If you’d like to chat about this, or any other topic, get in touch with us.

We lead People-Projects to success through communication.

Portrait of Simone Schmitt Schillig - Managing Director Unequity GmbH

Your contact person

Share this page directly: